What is the issue?
- US President Donald Trump has decided to pull all American troops out of Syria and reduce by half the US forces in Afghanistan.
- The move could have varied geopolitical and foreign policy implications for India's neighbourhood and the world.
What is Trump's rationale?
- The US has about 2,000 troops in Syria and 14,000 in Afghanistan.
- Right from his election campaign, Trump had criticised US military interventions in Afghanistan and Iraq as extremely expensive and politically foolish.
- Rather than spend American blood and treasure abroad to serve other people’s causes, Trump insisted he would put America First.
- He has been demanding a thorough overhaul of America’s external commitments.
- He claims that the physical infrastructure of the IS caliphate is destroyed.
- So the U.S. can leave the war against the remnants of the jihadist group to the Syrian government and its main backers, Russia and Iran.
- The caliphate is actually destroyed as the IS has lost 95% of the territory it once controlled.
- It is now confined to narrow pockets on the Iraqi-Syrian border.
- The U.S. would also not like to get stuck in Syria forever as it is basically Russia’s war.
- The U.S. is already stranded in Afghanistan (for 17 years) and Iraq (over 15 years) without a way out.
What are the risk factors of the move?
- The U.S. has only 2,000 troops in Syria, and they were not directly involved in the ground battle.
- They were supporting the Syrian Democratic Forces, a rebel group led by Kurdish rebels who were in the forefront of the fight against the IS.
- The U.S. support for the Kurdish rebels has irked Turkey.
- Turkey sees them as an extension of the Kurdistan Workers Party, the rebels on the Turkish side who have been fighting Turkish troops for decades.
- Turkey considers the military consolidation of Kurds as a strategic threat.
- In the past, Turkey had attacked Kurds in some pockets on the Syrian side, but was prevented from launching a full-throttle attack because of the U.S. presence.
- So the US pull out would in effect be leaving the Syrian Kurds at the mercy of Turkish troops.
- A risk factor will emerge if Turkey launches an attack on the Kurdish militants, which President Erdogan has vowed to do.
- The Kurds will then have to re-channel their resources to fight Turkish soldiers.
- This will weaken the ground resistance against the remaining IS militants on the southern side of the border.
What is the larger implication?
- The move marks the end of a prolonged phase of American military interventions in the Middle East and South Asia.
- The decision to pull troops out of Syria has predictably upset both the Washington establishment and America’s global allies.
- US Defence Secretary, James Mattis, who advised against the withdrawal, has resigned.
- Its internal tussle on its external relations is making U.S. an unpredictable factor in international politics.
- So the rest of the world has no option but to factor it into their own geopolitical calculus.
- Besides this, Trump’s move may undermine the war against the Islamic State.
- It would also help legitimise the Syrian ruler Bashar al Assad, and boost his backers in Moscow and Tehran.
- In Afghanistan, the decision comes at a time when US has embarked on direct talks with the Taliban brokered by Pakistan.
- India - If the decisions are implemented, India will have to take into account the consequences for its western neighbourhood.
- This is especially the case with Afghanistan where the U.S. has been fighting the longest war in American history.
- India must start preparing for the inevitable geopolitical turbulence.
- These may include the resurgence of the IS and the potential return of the Taliban to power in Kabul.
What could have been done?
- The ground reality is too complex and requires Mr. Trump to be more patient and strategic in his policymaking.
- He could have considered waiting for the conflict in the disturbed zones to de-escalate even further.
- Also, he could have gained assurances from Turkey that it would refrain from attacking Kurdish troops.
- The cost of being so abrupt is that it leaves a dangerous vacuum in north-eastern Syria.
Source: Indian Express, The Hindu
