0.2132
7667766266
x

Anatomy of Riots

iasparliament Logo
March 05, 2025

Why in News?

After the Delhi Assembly election results were announced, a fake controversial social media post sparked tensions in Udayagiri, in Mysuru.

What are the causes of riot?

  • Provocative social media posts –  Organised or random provocative contents of hate speeches on social media incites violence.
  • Extreme communal polarisation –  Division of society along religious or ethnic lines through social segregation and religious fundamentalism.
  • Exploitation of communal feelings - Riots are precipitated as a device to consolidate the support of ethnic, religious, or other culturally marked groups by emphasizing the need for solidarity in face of the rival communal group.
  • Majoritarianism - When minority community frequently comes under attack both online and offline, religious polarisation has intensified, and pent-up frustration is spilled on to the streets.
  • Backwardness – Socio economic backwardness of a region or community is potential ground for conflicts and riots.
  • Highly polarised polity - Competitive assertion of identities in a highly polarised polity offers varied forms of patronage to non-state actors.
  • Communalisation of state - Penetration of communal ideologies  in various domains of state and  state indifference or complicity.
  • Vicious cycle – All above factors feed each other in a vicious cycle online and in the real world.

Paul Brass’s Institutionalized riot systems

  • Institutionalized riot systems (IRS) is a term invented by professor Paul Brass in 2004 in his book The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence in Contemporary India with regards to Indian politics.
  • This term describes the dramatic production of riots, which Brass has divided into three phases.
    • Preparation, activation and explanation.
  • In the endemic riot prone regions , these three phases are continuous activities.

Preparation/ Rehearsal

  • This phase is a continuous activity.
  • The most important people in this phase are "fire tenders", who keep Hindu-Muslim tensions alive through various inflammatory and inciting acts.

Activation/Enactment

  • This phase is a phase of violence.
  • The activation takes place under particular circumstances, most notably in a context of intense political mobilization or electoral competition.
  • In this phase another group of people come forward, who lead and address mobs of potential rioters and give a signal to indicate if and when violence should start.
  • These leaders are called "conversion specialists".
  • They usually lead the mob of criminals from poor background, who were recruited and rewarded for practicing the violence.

Explanation/Interpretation

  • It follows after the violence in a broader struggle to control the explanation or interpretation of the causes of the violence.
  • In this phase, many other elements in society become involved, including journalists, politicians, social scientists, and public opinion generally.
  • Violence is presented as spontaneous, religious, mass-based, unpredictable and impossible to prevent.
  • Social scientists start the process of blame displacement to save those who are most responsible for the production of violence, and instead diffuses blame widely.
  • This contributes to the perpetuation of violent productions in future, as well as the order that sustains them.

What are the measures to manage  riots?

  • Legal Framework -  Sections 141 to 190  of Indian Penal Code (IPC) provides for preventive and punitive actions against unlawful assemblies.
  • Section 144 of the IPC - This section can be imposed to restrict public gatherings and prevent the spread of violence.
  • Disaster management – Riots and communal violence are included as part of state disaster management plans in Rajasthan and Meghalaya.
  • Social media monitoring cells –  These cells have been formed by district administration to monitor the social media posts and potential persons media accounts.
  • Establishment of Peace Committees - In riot-hit areas, peace committees comprising respected individuals from different communities are formed to mediate and restore peace
  • Proactive actions - Police have filed numerous suo motu cases whenever they come across such “inflammatory and derogatory” content.
  • Development – Regional and community  development is essential in addressing the communal riots.
  • Press Briefings - Frequent media briefings help prevent misinformation and keep the public informed about developments.
  • Fact check units – Various government and news media have created fact checking platforms to enable people verity news.

What are the challenges in addressing riot situation?

  • Viral contents prevention - Identifying such potentially provocative content before it goes viral is a major challenge.
  • Resource limitation - Limited software that the district cells have is not compatible with regional languages, does not read what is written on images and scans only posts.
  • Vast volumes of content – Social media is indefinitely vast with different open platforms such as Facebook and X and billions of users to check for objectionable content.
  • Monitoring private channels – Privacy settings in WhatsApp and Telegram makes the monitoring of circulation of provocative contents close to impossible.
  • Overreach - Social media monitoring by the police has also led to overreach, with many cases being booked against people for criticising the ruling party.
  • Technological evolution – Rise of artificial intelligence and deep fakes makes it difficult to separate the reality and fake audio, images , video.

What lied ahead?

  • Community outreach and trust between the local police, leadership, and the community can prevent escalation of situations.
  • Use of advanced technologies like Artificial intelligence , Big data to monitor social media platforms to prevent the circulation of provocative contents.
  • Coordination between different departments and levels of government is crucial for effective response and recovery.
  • Media education and awareness creation among people about the potential misuse of advanced technologies.

Reference

The Hindu | Anatomy of Riot

For Mains practice question, Click here.

Login or Register to Post Comments
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to review.

ARCHIVES

MONTH/YEARWISE ARCHIVES

sidetext
Free UPSC Interview Guidance Programme
sidetext